
Meta has been fined €805 million by Italy’s data protection authority over a Facebook feature that accesses photos and videos stored in Android users’ phone galleries to suggest content they can share on the platform.
The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as Garante, ruled that the feature was activated by default and accessed users’ photos, videos and related metadata without obtaining their explicit consent.
The company has been given 60 days to disable the feature by default, including for users who had previously granted Facebook permission to access their phone galleries. It must also introduce a separate consent request specifically explaining how the feature works and what information it accesses.
Meta has described the penalty as disproportionate and announced plans to appeal the decision, according to a statement by a company spokesperson reported by Reuters.
The investigation found that Facebook relied on a single permission request covering several app functions with different purposes. Although users were initially presented with a general notification about enabling additional features, the authority said the explanation did not clearly disclose that granting access would also activate photo and video suggestions from their phone galleries.
Once permission is granted, the app can potentially access a user’s entire photo archive on an ongoing basis. The authority noted that neither users nor regulators could independently establish exactly which information was being accessed and used.
The regulator said Meta’s practices violated Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive. The provision protects information stored on users’ devices by requiring free and informed consent before companies access it, regardless of whether the information is subsequently transmitted elsewhere or causes harm.
Under the enforcement order, Meta must introduce a separate and specific consent request within 60 days, clearly explaining the purpose of the feature, its access to users’ galleries and how it can be disabled.
The company must also ensure that the feature remains switched off by default, even for users who had previously authorised gallery access.
Additionally, Meta is required to submit an initial report to the authority within 30 days detailing the steps it has begun taking to comply. A further report outlining the measures implemented must be submitted within 90 days.
Failure to meet the 60-day deadline means the feature cannot be activated for users who have not provided valid consent.
Meta maintained that the feature operates only after users grant permission through their device settings. The company also argued that users can withdraw or modify the permission whenever they choose.
The investigation followed a complaint filed by the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection organisation based in Bolzano. The group had raised concerns about Facebook accessing photographs that users had not published.
In July 2025, the organisation advised Facebook users to disable gallery suggestion settings and review the permissions granted to the app on their Android devices.
The Italian authority’s investigation did not examine whether photographs accessed through the feature were used to train artificial intelligence models. Meta has denied using the content for such purposes.
However, the regulator may separately examine a newer feature introduced this year that allows content from users’ phone galleries to be processed through cloud-based systems.
Meta had also argued that the case should be handled by Ireland’s data protection authority. The Italian regulator rejected the position, explaining that the ePrivacy rules involved do not provide for the EU’s one-stop-shop mechanism for cross-border data protection cases.
The gallery suggestion feature has reportedly been available since 2023, while the Italian investigation began in July 2025 and included technical examinations conducted by the regulator.
The €805 million penalty represents approximately 0.47 per cent of Meta’s global revenue. In determining the amount, the authority considered the scale of the affected population, estimated at about 20 million Android users in Italy.
It also took into account the duration of the violation, noting that the practice remained ongoing for users who had not updated their applications and those who had previously granted gallery permissions.
Other factors considered included a previous regulatory decision against Meta in 2019 and what the authority described as limited cooperation during the investigation.
Changes introduced by Meta after the complaint were considered mitigating factors, although the regulator concluded that the adjustments came late and were limited in scope because they mainly benefited users who updated their applications.



